Let's Stop the Doodle Hate: Defending Responsible, Ethical, State-Licensed Breeders Who Pay Taxes

Why do People Hate Doodles?

In a world where canine fashionistas strut their stuff, one question perplexes the masses: Why the disdain for Doodles? These delightful hybrids, sporting their sweet and wavy coats, have sparked a fur-raising debate among dog aficionados and breeders alike. Despite their growing popularity as an alternative to purebreds, Doodles and their breeders find themselves in the doghouse of skepticism and criticism. But let’s leash our prejudices for a moment and take a paws to explore the real bark behind the bite of Doodle breeding.

Exploring the Controversy

Ah, the 'Doodle hate'—it's a tale as old as time, fueled by accusations of contributing to shelter overcrowding, sketchy breeding practices, and diluting pedigrees faster than a spilt water bowl. Detractors argue that these mixed breeds are as predictable as a squirrel in a dog park, inheriting the worst traits of their lineage. They dismiss Doodle breeding as nothing more than a cash-grabbing trend, conveniently forgetting that all dog breeds were essentially custom-made to fit human desires. But why throw shade at these breeders, when they're just trying to make an honest living, one paw print at a time?

The Benefits of Doodle Breeding

Before we unleash our fury on Doodles, let’s not forget the regal history of their Poodle ancestors. These majestic creatures weren’t just fluffy fashion statements; they were bred for a purpose—whether it was retrieving game or charming nobility with their elegant locks. And let’s face it, mixing Poodle genes with other breeds isn’t some canine conspiracy; it’s just evolution at its finest.

Doodles aren’t just a passing fancy; they’re a practical choice for allergy sufferers and families in need of a furry friend. Their popularity isn’t just a result of clever marketing—it’s a testament to their charm and companionship. From compact Cockapoos perfect for city living to Labradoodles with enough spirit to rival a wolf, Doodles cater to a variety of lifestyles. So, before we dismiss them as mere mutts, let’s acknowledge the paw-sitive impact they have on people's lives.

Responsible Doodle Breeding Practices

It's crucial to differentiate between the archetype of an irresponsible 'backyard breeder' and professional breeders who adhere to ethical standards, regulations, and governing tax law. Yes, we charge and pay tax, because we’re a business. It should be a red flag to anyone who sells dogs any other way.

Summary:

For professional dog breeders, understanding the distinction between a hobby and a business is crucial for tax reporting and deductions. Regardless of the classification, all income from sales must be reported and taxed accordingly. In the case of a hobby, sales are reported as Other Income without the ability to deduct related expenses. To be recognized as a business, breeders must demonstrate a clear profit motive, maintain meticulous records, and operate in line with other successful enterprises.

Establishing separate bank accounts and forming a Limited Liability Company (LLC) can signal a serious business intent, offering both financial protection and a structured business framework. The IRS assesses various factors such as expertise, time investment, and profitability trends over multiple years to determine the legitimacy of the breeding operation.

Professional breeders must also navigate employment regulations when hiring assistance, ensuring compliance with Employee or Independent Contractor rules for tax reporting purposes. Deductions related to Business Use of Home, Vehicle expenses, Travel, Lodging & Meals are available but require accurate recordkeeping and adherence to IRS guidelines.

Ultimately, for professional dog breeders, the focus should be on demonstrating a genuine intent to generate profit, adapting operations for profitability, maintaining comprehensive records, and adhering to tax regulations to avoid potential issues with the IRS.

Additionally, reputable professional Doodle breeders are no different in their commitment to the health, well-being, and future of their pups. They take it seriously. It isn’t a hobby! They live and breathe it every day and it provides for their family and supports they dogs they care for.

Such breeders invest in genetic testing, carefully select pairings to avoid hereditary issues, and raise puppies with the care they deserve. They are also transparent with potential adopters about the variability in traits and the dedicated maintenance often required for a Doodle's coat. They invest in:

Quality breeding stock, Veterinary care, Genetic testing, Nutritionally balanced food, Whelping supplies (whelping box, heat lamps, scales), Vaccinations and deworming treatments, Marketing materials (website, advertising), Kennel facilities or improvements, Grooming equipment, Training and socialization programs, Registration fees, Legal and professional services (consulting, contracts), Transportation (crates, carriers), Show or competition expenses, Breeding and reproductive health screenings, Insurance (liability, health), Continuing education and certifications, Technology (computers, software), Maintenance and repairs for facilities, Emergency funds for unexpected expenses… just to name a few.

Let’s bark up the right tree here: responsible breeders aren’t the enemy. They’re the unsung heroes of the canine kingdom, ensuring the health and well-being of their pups with every tail wag. While some may scoff at the idea of paying top dollar for a well-bred doodle, let’s remember that quality comes at a price—just like artisanal cheese or designer shoes.

Addressing Concerns and Improving the Reputation

Acknowledging concerns regarding Doodle breeding is essential. The potential for genetic health problems and the oversaturation of the market are legitimate worries that demand responsible action. Stokehire is taking strides in establishing breed standards and tracing lineage, which is a step towards acknowledging the breed's long-term presence in the dog world. Our DNA database ensures we reduce the COIs of our puppies, reducing the potential for inheritable diseases.

Additionally, educational resources provided by breeders and enthusiast communities about proper care, health concerns, and training specifically for Doodle varieties can empower current and future owners, benefiting both the dogs and the greater breeding community.

Decreasing Shelters, Elevating Standards

In the realm of pet ownership, luxury doesn't have to be the enemy of compassion, especially when our purchases and preferences distinctly shape the broader narrative of animal welfare. The community of responsible breeders and aficionados of high-end canines, often demonized as a mainstay of shelter overpopulation, is misunderstood. In this thought-provoking exposition, we'll stride against the stream by unveiling a perspective that celebrates the conscientious acquisition of luxury, well-bred pets. Far from exacerbating the shelter conundrum, this progressive approach fosters a culture of sustained care and integrity in pet stewardship, effectively lowering the number of animals in need of adoption and sanctuary.

A Sheltered Misconception: The Luxury Link

The notion that high-priced, meticulously well-bred dogs are a gateway to shelter inhabitants is a common fallacy. Critics and trolls alike boil the issue down to a stark equation of supply and demand, assuming that luxurious dog markets inflate the need for rescue animals. However, the reality is far more intricate. Investments in purebreds from reputable sources serve as a preventative pivot: raising the bar for the type of care and commitment an owner is willing to offer. The adopt-don't-shop mantra, while well-intentioned, lacks the depth to account for the indirect, shelter-deterrent effects of luxury pet patronage.

Beneath the Surface: Breeder Responsiveness

Enter the conscientious breeders—the unsung heroes of animal philanthropy. Premier dog artisans like Stokeshire Designer Doodles don’t operate in the shadowy confines of back-alley puppy mills; we strive to be beacons of ethical practice, often outperforming the standards of shelter establishments. Responsible breeders meticulously screen clients, ensure a dog's health through comprehensive vetting and do not shy away from reclaiming dogs if an adoptive environment falters. These breeders reflect a paradigm shift in animal custodianship, signaling to the greater public that pet ownership is a commitment, not a commodity. We’re setting new standards.

Luxury as a Learning Paradigm

By privileging well-bred, high-quality pets, individuals fortify an implicit agreement that the bond between owner and pet is one of responsibility and devotion. In contrast to the disposable culture that sometimes permeates the 'rescue-only' mindset, the luxury model inspires a more measured, discerning approach to companionship where each purchase is a lifelong promise. The elegant canines that grace the estates of the affluent are more than designer labels—they are symbols of an elevated standard of care and intentionality.

The Sheltering Effect of Versatile Dogs

The conflation of breed standards with intrinsic worth is an outdated fixture. Yet, it’s undeniable that specific types of dogs are bred for distinct traits, be it temperament, hypoallergenic qualities, working capabilities, or health resilience. Versatile breeds with predictable characteristics are less likely to be relinquished, serving their owners in a variety of roles with minimal surprises. This predictability, often derided as commodification, is a practical manifestation of breeder diligence that aligns with the wishes of prospective pet parents seeking stability in their homes.

Spoiled for Choice, Not for Care

Critics contend that high-end pets are disproportionately pampered at the expense of their more modestly acquired counterparts. However, the reality paints a different picture. The luxury of investment comes with heightened scrutiny that trickles down to enriched educational materials, veterinary services, and training regimens, culminating in a pet that embodies health and discipline. The dollars spent on a luxury breed translate into a currency of preparedness, reducing the likelihood of pets being surrendered due to unexpected difficulties.

Crafting a Narrative of Care

Luxury pet ownership should not be viewed through the monochromatic lens of privilege. Instead, it offers an opportunity to rescript the pet welfare narrative, emphasizing preparation, commitment, and quality. Breeders and consumers who champion luxury breeds are weaving an epic tale of care—one where animals are intentionally and properly placed in loving homes. This narrative contrasts with the often-disjointed storylines of shelters struggling to rehome a diverse, sometimes unpredictable, range of animals with trauma.

The Invisible Leash: Responsible Breeding Best Practices

What sets responsible breeders apart, and should therefore be celebrated, are the exacting standards they apply to their craft. These artisans of the canine world champion health, disposition, and breed integrity. Their dedication results in animals that are less likely to experience the upheaval of shelter life, offering prospective owners a tangible alternative to the uncertainties that sometimes accompany rescue pets.

Luxe with a Leash: The Way Forward

Our perspective should evolve from casting judgment on luxury pet markets to recognizing the fundamental choice and responsibility luxury pet enthusiasts embody. Engaging with this market segment offers an exciting opportunity to underscore animal welfare as a priority and a possibility. It’s not about rejecting the call to rescue; it’s about expanding the conversation to include the nuanced pathways that lead to a kinder, more informed approach to pet ownership.

Breeding 101: A Lesson for the Ignorant Doodle-Hater Troll

This one is for you. Cognitive dissonance is a BITCH! Receiving new information: Learning new information that conflicts with existing beliefs or attitudes can lead to cognitive dissonance as the person tries to reconcile the new information with their current beliefs. That is what is about to happen. So hold on.

News Flash. There are no purebred dogs! Do you know what purebred means? "Purebred" refers to an animal, typically a dog or a cat, whose ancestors are all of the same breed. In other words, a purebred animal has a documented pedigree tracing back multiple generations, with each ancestor belonging to the same recognized breed.

To be considered purebred, an animal must meet the specific standards and characteristics set forth by its breed's breed club or kennel club. These standards typically outline physical traits, temperament, and other qualities that define the breed.

Purebred animals are often bred for specific purposes, such as herding, hunting, or companionship, and their lineage is carefully managed to maintain the breed's traits and characteristics over time.

It's important to note that purebred animals have a predictable appearance and temperament due to their breeding because they are all descended from very closely related ancestors, making them cousins. they are not necessarily healthier or better than mixed-breed animals. Purebred animals may be more prone to certain genetic health issues due to the limited gene pool within the breed.

We tried this with humans a few times, it didn’t go well. House of Habsburg anyone? If you don’t understand breeding and the history of breeding you likely won’t get the reference. One of the most well-known issues associated with the Habsburg dynasty is the practice of inbreeding, particularly among its Spanish branch. Intermarriage between close relatives was common to maintain control over inherited territories and wealth. This practice led to a high degree of genetic homogeneity within the Habsburg bloodline and increased the likelihood of genetic disorders and health problems among descendants. The most notable consequence of inbreeding was the prevalence of physical and mental disabilities among Habsburg rulers, including Charles II of Spain, who was severely disabled and infertile. Doesn’t that sound like a great idea!? In fact, in most states it is illegal. The canid family, Canidae, encompasses a wide range of species, each with distinct genetic characteristics that are incredibly diverse. Canids are also capable of hybridization. O’ the terror. How dare they. Don’t they know they’re only supposed to have sex with their second cousins to remain pure? Hitler would be so proud. This is sarcasm, perfect for those who need a GPS to find a punchline!

I digress.

Furthermore, do you know how modern breeds spontaneously came to be? Was it evolution? Maybe an internet troll or purest poodle breeder waved their wand and 400 dog breeds emerged all without a breeder’s help. Maybe a vet made them in a lab? Or a much more likely reality and dare I say, the “truth” - they were ‘designed’ by breeders from across the world spaning hundreds of years of effort.

Let’s take the Australian Shepherd, a Stokeshire favorite, and a relatively new breed. Most modern dog breeds came into existence relatively recently, within the past few hundred years. The development of distinct dog breeds accelerated significantly during the 19th century with the rise of dog shows, which emphasized specific breed standards and characteristics. However, the origins of some breeds can be traced back much further, with ancient breeds like the Saluki, Basenji, and Afghan Hound having pedigrees that stretch back thousands of years.

Humans selectively bred different dog breeds for specific purposes like hunting, herding, guarding, and companionship. While some breeds were developed for working roles, others were bred for looks or status. Modern breeds have ties to older breeds or landrace populations that existed for centuries. Crossbreeding and creating new breeds continue to occur, reflecting changing human preferences and functional requirements.

The Australian Shepherd's ancestry is a blend of various herding breeds, shaped over time through selective breeding. Breeds like the Border Collie and Collie, known for their herding prowess, likely influenced its development. Additionally, the rugged Australian Cattle Dog and agile Pyrenean Shepherd may have contributed certain traits. Basque Shepherds, who migrated to the United States, possibly brought their dogs, further enriching the gene pool. Despite speculation, the exact mix of breeds remains uncertain due to the breed's history in remote ranching areas and sparse breeding records.

Similarly, the Bernese Mountain Dog's heritage is a tapestry woven from the threads of several working breeds, meticulously bred over generations. Breeds such as the sturdy Molossers likely provided the foundation for its robust build, while Mastiffs may have imparted their protective instincts. Indigenous Swiss Mountain Dogs, like the Greater Swiss Mountain Dog and the Entlebucher Mountain Dog, share similarities with the Bernese in appearance and purpose, suggesting a shared ancestry. Additionally, interactions with local herding dogs and other versatile working breeds in the Swiss Alps further shaped the Bernese's traits. Despite these influences, the precise blend of breeds remains elusive, owing to the breed's historical roots in rural Switzerland and the scarcity of detailed breeding records.

And lastly, just because some Poodle Breeders need a history lesson and are some of the most fascist elitists out there, no offense if you’re a poodle breeder, we breed poodles too!

The Poodle's ancestry is a mosaic of several European water-retrieving breeds, carefully cultivated over time through selective breeding. Originating in Germany, the breed's lineage includes contributions from water dogs like the Barbet and various German hunting breeds. The Barbet, whose weight ranges between 30-60 pounds, is believed to be the ancestor of several of today’s popular breeds, including the Poodle, Bichon Frise, Otterhound, Newfoundland, Briard, and others. The Poodle's distinctive coat and elegant appearance were refined through crosses with dogs like the Hungarian Water Dog and the Spanish Water Dog. Additionally, the breed's intelligence and trainability owe much to its roots as a working retriever. Despite its aristocratic image, the Poodle's heritage is deeply rooted in practicality and utility. However, the exact combination of breeds that contributed to the Poodle's development may remain somewhat speculative due to the breed's extensive history and diverse influences.

Did you read any similarities here? We hope so. I won't explain more because it would be repetitive. This shouldn’t be new information. Take some time. Some need guttural troll-like breaths, watch the Hobbit, it’s time to come out of the mines and out from behind your screen and go visit a dog park. The sun, the grass, the dogs… it’s all beautiful. Imagine, you might actually have a nice day or say something kind to someone. Here, I will give you an example. “Good dog.” It’s a great launching point. Imagine the possibilities.

CounterArgument & response

There are arguments against the idea that luxury pet markets reduce shelter populations. Some may argue that responsible breeders may ensure buyers are vetted and offer guarantees, but the demand for luxury breeds may indirectly contribute to the overpopulation of shelters. The high price tags associated with luxury breeds could incentivize irresponsible breeding practices elsewhere, which may result in more dogs being abandoned or surrendered to shelters due to health or behavioral issues. Also, the focus on designer breeds may divert attention and resources away from adopting shelter dogs, which could further contribute to shelter overcrowding.

On the other hand, some may argue that mixed-breed dogs are not equal to purebred dogs. They may emphasize that purebred dogs offer consistency and predictability in terms of appearance and behavior, as they are bred to conform to specific standards. Responsible breeding practices often include health screenings to mitigate genetic health risks. Additionally, purebred dogs have been selectively bred for generations for specific roles, resulting in specialized traits and abilities. Breed recognition and pedigree documentation also assure owners. While both types of dogs offer companionship, purebred dogs may better suit owners seeking predictability, purposeful breeding, and breed-specific traits.

While there may be concerns regarding the indirect contribution of luxury pet markets to shelter populations, it's essential to recognize the nuanced dynamics at play. Responsible breeders uphold stringent standards to ensure the well-being of their dogs and the suitability of potential owners. Additionally, the demand for luxury breeds doesn't necessarily lead to an increase in shelter surrenders, as reputable breeders actively work to prevent such outcomes. Furthermore, the focus on designer breeds shouldn't overshadow the ongoing efforts to promote shelter adoptions. Both avenues can coexist, with each serving different preferences and needs within the pet community.

Regarding the comparison between mixed-breed and purebred dogs, it's important to acknowledge that each type offers unique benefits. While purebred dogs may indeed provide consistency and predictability in appearance and behavior, mixed-breed dogs often exhibit hybrid vigor and may be less prone to certain genetic health issues. Moreover, mixed-breed dogs contribute to the diversity of the canine population and can make wonderful companions. Ultimately, the choice between purebred and mixed-breed dogs depends on individual preferences and priorities, with both types deserving of love and care.

The 'Doodle hate' refers to the negative attitude towards crossbreed dogs that are a mix of Poodles and other breeds. However, this attitude fails to acknowledge the diverse reality of these unique dogs. While it's important to discourage unethical breeding practices, it's unfair to criticize responsible breeders who genuinely care for their animals.

Ethical breeders and conscientious pet buyers contribute significantly to the welfare of animals. Rather than harming shelter populations, high-end dog markets help alleviate the issues that afflict them. We should appreciate the value that Doodle breeders bring to the dog breeding community and celebrate the happiness that their dogs bring to our lives.

Ultimately, we should focus on responsibility and welfare to ensure that every wagging tail—whether it's curled, straight, short, or long—is celebrated for the joy it brings. Let's promote inclusivity in the dog breeding community and work together to sustain happy homes for our beloved companions. If you come across a dog priced at $400 on Facebook or Craigslist, or a photo of a litter of puppies in a cardboard box, feel free to direct your frustration towards those individuals who are contributing to the problem of shelter overcrowding. However, before unleashing your inner troll or purest AKC self, perhaps consider starting by simply being a good person.