The Predictive Value of Early Behavioral Assessments in Dogs: Does Puppy Testing Matter?

Understanding a dog's behavior from an early age has significant implications, aiding in matching pups with suitable families, identifying potential behavioral issues early on, and predicting their suitability for specialized roles like therapy, service, police, or military work. However, assessing behavior during a dog's early socialization period has yielded inconsistent results in the literature. Some practitioners use tests on neonates to aid in choosing working dogs, but these methods lack validation.

A recent longitudinal study focusing on Border collies aimed to bridge this gap. The study followed these dogs from neonate to adulthood, conducting behavioral tests at various stages. The neonate test assessed activity, vocalizations when isolated, and sucking force. At 40–50 days old, puppies underwent a puppy test at their breeders' homes, and some participated in an adult behavioral test at 1.5 to 2 years old with their owners.

Surprisingly, the study found minimal consistency between behaviors exhibited during the neonate, puppy, and adult tests. Only exploratory activity showed a significant correlation between the puppy and adult tests. This suggests that early tests' predictive validity for specific behavioral traits in adult pet dogs is limited.

The study delved into the idea that animals, much like humans, display behavioral differences, but these may not remain fixed over time or situations. Behavioral consistency tends to decrease as time passes between tests, influenced by various factors like developmental changes and life experiences.

In human studies, personality traits become more stable with age, although some traits may change. Attempts to predict behavioral predispositions shortly after birth have shown moderate success, particularly in measuring irritability or distress levels in infants.

When it comes to dogs, behavioral development studies aim to aid in various practical applications, including selecting the right families and predicting suitability for different roles. Yet, the predictive value of early tests, especially before three months of age, remains debated.

The Border Collie study's findings underscore the limitations of early tests in foretelling future behavior in dogs. While some studies have suggested predictability for outcomes like guide or police dog success, they often lack consistency in predicting individual behavioral traits.

Several factors may contribute to this inconsistency, including the age at which tests are conducted, environmental influences, and the dog's socialization experiences. The study highlights that experiences throughout a dog's life, especially during adolescence, significantly shape their behavior.

Moreover, the influence of genetics, early environment, and later environmental factors plays a crucial role in a dog's behavior. While early litter effects were noticeable in younger puppies, they diminished as the dogs matured, emphasizing the impact of environmental influences on shaping behavior.

The study's key takeaway is a caution against over-reliance on early behavioral assessments in predicting a dog's future behavior. It emphasizes the importance of considering experiential factors throughout a dog's life in understanding and interpreting their behavior accurately. This insight marks just the beginning of understanding dogs' behavioral development, urging further research into developmental trajectories to make more informed predictions about a dog's behavior later in life.

In conclusion, while scientific studies offer invaluable insights into behavioral assessments in dogs, it's important to acknowledge the limitations and complexities in predicting a dog's future behavior solely based on early tests. At Stokeshire, our commitment to excellence extends to the meticulous evaluation of our puppies. These assessments aid us in selecting puppies for retention and help pair families with the most suitable companions. Despite the insights gained from research, our focus remains on dedicating extra time and attention to our puppies, showcasing our dedication to providing the best for both our clients and our dogs. Our intentionality in understanding and evaluating each puppy's unique traits reflects our commitment to serving our clients and ensuring the well-being and happiness of our beloved dogs.

---

Source:

Riemer, Stefanie, et al. “The Predictive Value of Early Behavioural Assessments in Pet Dogs – a Longitudinal Study from Neonates to Adults.” PLOS ONE, vol. 9, no. 7, 8 July 2014, pp. e101237–e101237, www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4086890/?fbclid=IwAR07lmvcJ-DFguvZfXrqfEEs8jkJSOOt0egB2qh8xBRuDOv8KbueV3D4DZc, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0101237. Accessed 22 Dec. 2023.

‌